diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index 1b91003..2e737f6 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -8907,3 +8907,45 @@ MERGE_CHECKLIST.md (Tier 3 from cycle #70) successfully guided: --- + +--- + +## Cycle #75 Integration Attempt: Manual Rebase Too Complex for Multi-Conflict Branches + +**Date:** 2026-04-23 04:32 Seoul. + +**Attempt:** Execute rebase-bridge pattern for #248. Fetch origin/feat/jobdori-248, cherry-pick onto main, resolve conflicts. + +**Finding:** The manual conflict resolution is **not scalable** for branches with 2+ conflict zones in the same file. Specifically: + +1. **First conflict (line 284):** Merging #247 additions (prompt error classifications) + #248 additions (verb-option error classifications) — resolved cleanly by combining both. +2. **Second conflict (line 11119):** Test function definitions colliding (both `#[test]` functions). After removing conflict markers via regex, Rust compiler still reports "encountered diff marker" — unclear source. + +**Root cause:** The `main.rs` file is now 12,000+ lines with densely packed test definitions. When two feature branches both add test functions + error classification rules, conflict resolution requires understanding both test suites deeply AND reconstructing exact formatting. + +**Decision:** The rebase-bridge pattern **works for 1-commit branches** (e.g., a single focused fix), but **breaks down for branches with 2+ conflicts in large files**. + +--- + +## Revised Integration Strategy: Push Main to Origin, Request Upstream Rebase + +Given the complexity, **better path forward:** + +1. Push current main (1,006 commits) to origin main branch +2. Request branch authors (gaebal-gajae, Jobdori) to: + - Fetch origin/main (updated with cycles #72–#75) + - Rebase their local branches onto new main + - Force-push to origin +3. Then merge from updated origin branches + - Authors have full IDE context, can resolve conflicts properly + - Less opaque than script-based regex + manual repair + - Creates natural PR → review → merge trail + +**Why this is better:** +- Authors understand their own changes +- No hidden conflict-marker remnants (like we hit in cycle #75) +- Cleaner audit trail +- Parallel: multiple authors can rebase simultaneously + +--- +