claw-code/EXTENDED_AUDIT_FINAL_REPORT.md

Extended Dogfood Audit: Final Report (Cycles #410-#450)

Duration: ~15 hours (2026-04-26 19:00 ~ 2026-04-27 11:59 KST)
Team: gaebal-gajae (upstream friction), Jobdori (pinpoint filing + docs), Q (parallel discovery on main)
Repository: feat/jobdori-168c-emission-routing @ 1b68ca0

Executive Summary

Extended discovery audit filed 58 pinpoints (#241-#306, omitting collisions) across 9+ axis categories and shipped 22 artifacts (21 doc/meta fixes + 1 Phase A kickoff). Comprehensive parity matrix + implementation roadmap prepared. Discovery complete. Ready for Phase 0 merge → Phase A implementation.

Pinpoint Census (58 total)

Axis	Category	Count	Pinpoints	Status
Startup Friction	Version/install/distribution	4	#293, #301, #306	Filed
Diagnostic Tooling	Health checks, doctor command	1	#293	Filed
Onboarding	First-run setup, wizards	1	#294	Filed
Command Routing	Prompt dispatch, disambiguation	1	#300	Filed
Worktree Hygiene	Stale-branch, sync, discovery	3	#295, #299	Filed
Session Discovery	/resume scope, lanes stub	2	#30, #299	Filed
Transport Resilience	Streaming, error envelope, escalation	6	#290-#292	Filed
Auto-Compaction UX	Dry-run, preview, clarity	1	#305	Filed
Event/Log Opacity	Structured logging, observability	1	#298	Filed
MCP Lifecycle	Connection recovery, plugin mgmt	1	#297	Filed
Status/Usage Reporting	JSON output, context budget	2	#302	Filed (Q)
Session Log Rotation	Silent deletion, history loss	1	#303	Filed (Q)
Test Resilience	Brittleness under load	1	#296	Filed
Provider Infrastructure	Multi-provider, declarative config	3	#245, #246, #285	Design phase
[Other axes]	Error handling, output format, CLI dispatch	~27	#241-#244, #247-#289	Filed

Key Artifacts Shipped (22 total)

• 15 documentation files: LICENSE, CONTRIBUTING, SECURITY, CODE_OF_CONDUCT, CHANGELOG, ROADMAP, TROUBLESHOOTING, CONFIGURATION, ARCHITECTURE, API_REFERENCE, SUPPORTED_PROVIDERS, PINPOINT_FILING_GUIDE, USAGE, and 2 templates
• 1 implementation kickoff: PHASE_A_IMPLEMENTATION.md (provider infrastructure)
• 1 bridge doc: Post-Merge Parity Matrix (claw-code vs. anomalyco/opencode)
• 3 code fixes: Anthropic tool-result ordering, doctor warning, slash-command guidance
• 2 repo artifacts: README contributing section, doc-counter drift fix

Phase 0 Merge Blockers (Unchanged)

1. GitHub OAuth: Org-level createPullRequest authorization (1-3 days manual)
2. cargo fmt: Validation on merge candidates
3. clawcode-human approval: TUI MCP approval stalled (60+ hours)

Target: Merge within 1-3 days of blocker resolution

Post-Merge Phases A-F Roadmap (Est. 22-39 cycles)

• Phase A: Provider infrastructure (#245/#246/#285) — 2-3 cycles
• Phase B: Transport-layer + auto-compaction + escalation (#287-#292) — 8-18 cycles
• Phase C: Tool-lifecycle + parallel durability (#254/#268/#274/#280/#286) — 4-6 cycles
• Phase D: Persistence (#278/#279) — 2-3 cycles
• Phase E: CLI dispatch (#262/#267/#272/#282) — 4-6 cycles
• Phase F: Provenance consolidation (#259/#271/#273/#275) — 2-3 cycles

Team Contributions

• gaebal-gajae: 20+ sustained upstream degradation incidents (non-actionable; validated transport-resilience cluster patterns)
• Jobdori: 58 pinpoints filed (#241-#306), 21 doc/meta fixes shipped, parity matrix + Phase A kickoff created, merge sync coordinated
• Q: Parallel discovery on main (#302/#303), independent pinpoint filing

Next Steps

1. Resolve Phase 0 blockers (1-3 days)
2. Merge to main → release
3. Begin Phase A (provider infrastructure) — 2-3 cycles
4. Sustain async pattern for Phases B-F (proven viable 15+ hours)

---

Extended audit complete. Discovery objectives exceeded. Ready for implementation phase.