SCHEMAS.md locks JSON envelope contract for all 14 clawable commands.
No corresponding contract for text output (--output-format text).
Text output is ad hoc per-command: no documented format, no column ordering
guarantee, no stability contract. Claws parsing text output have no safety.
Filed as discovery gap from systematic doc audit (cycle #83). Design options:
- Option A: Document text contracts (parallel to JSON) — 4 dev-days
- Option B: Declare text unstable, point to JSON — 1 dev-day (recommended)
- Option C: Defer until post-#164 JSON migration
Related to #164 (JSON migration) and #250 (surface parity audit).
The aspirational SCHEMAS.md doc (v2.0 target) was the source of truth misdocumentation.
Three downstream docs (USAGE, ERROR_HANDLING, CLAUDE) inherited the false claim that
v1.0 binary emits common fields it doesn't actually emit.
Fixing SCHEMAS.md at the source eliminates the root cause for all four P0 instances.
Doc-truthfulness P0 family now complete: 4/4 closed, root cause identified + fixed.
All fixes shipped within 6 cycles (#76 audit → #82 execution).
SCHEMAS.md was presenting the target v2.0 schema as the current binary contract.
This is the source of truth document, so the misdocumentation propagated to every
downstream doc (USAGE.md, ERROR_HANDLING.md, CLAUDE.md all inherited the false
premise that v1.0 includes timestamp/command/exit_code/etc).
Fixed with:
1. CRITICAL header at top: marks entire doc as v2.0 target, not v1.0 reality
2. 'TARGET v2.0 SCHEMA' headers on Common Fields section
3. Comprehensive Appendix: v1.0 actual shape + migration timeline + v1.0 code example
4. Links to FIX_LOCUS_164.md + ERROR_HANDLING.md for v1.0 reality
5. FAQ: clarifies the version mismatch and when v2.0 ships
This closes the fourth P0 doc-truthfulness instance (4/4 in family):
- #78 USAGE.md: active misdocumentation (fixed#78)
- #79 ERROR_HANDLING.md: copy-paste trap (fixed#79)
- #165 CLAUDE.md: boundary collapse (fixed#81)
- #166 SCHEMAS.md: aspirational source doc (fixed#82)
Pattern is now crystallized: SCHEMAS.md was the aspirational source;
three downstream docs (USAGE, ERROR_HANDLING, CLAUDE) inherited the false v2.0-as-v1.0
claim. Fix the source (SCHEMAS.md), which eliminates the root cause for all four.
CLAUDE.md Option A implemented. P0 doc-truthfulness family now at 3 closed +
0 open (all 3 fixed within the same dogfood session).
Taxonomy refinement added: P0 doc-truthfulness has three distinct subclasses:
- active misdocumentation (false sentence) — USAGE.md cycle #78
- copy-paste trap (broken example code) — ERROR_HANDLING.md cycle #79
- target/current boundary collapse (v2.0 as v1.0) — CLAUDE.md cycle #81
All three related to #164 (envelope divergence). Root cause consistent across
family; remedies differ per subclass.
CLAUDE.md was documenting the v2.0 target schema as if it were current binary
behavior. This misled validator/harness implementers into assuming the Rust
binary emits timestamp, command, exit_code, output_format, schema_version fields
when it doesn't.
Fixed by explicitly marking the boundary:
1. SCHEMAS.md section: now clearly labels 'target v2.0 design' and lists both
v1.0 (actual binary) and v2.0 (target) field shapes
2. Clawable commands requirements: now explicitly separates v1.0 (current) and
v2.0 (post-FIX_LOCUS_164) envelope requirements
3. Added inline migration note pointing to FIX_LOCUS_164.md
This closes#165 as the third P0 doc-truthfulness fix (Option A: preserve current
truth, add v2.0 target as separate labeled section).
P0 doc-truthfulness family pattern (all three related to #164 envelope divergence):
- #78 USAGE.md: active misdocumentation (fixed cycle #78)
- #79 ERROR_HANDLING.md: copy-paste trap (fixed cycle #79)
- #165 CLAUDE.md: target/current boundary collapse (fixed cycle #81)
CLAUDE.md claims 'Common fields (all envelopes): timestamp, command, exit_code,
output_format, schema_version' but the actual binary v1.0 doesn't emit these.
This is aspirational (v2.0 target from SCHEMAS.md) documented as current behavior
in a file that's supposed to describe the Python reference harness.
Filed as 3rd member of doc-truthfulness P0 family (joins #78, #79).
Both options documented: update CLAUDE.md for v1.0 OR clarify it's v2.0 aspirational.
Recommendation: Option A (keep CLAUDE.md truthful about actual validation).
Part of broader #164 family (envelope schema divergence across all docs).
Formalizes a 4-level severity scale for documentation-vs-implementation divergence:
- P0: Active misdocumentation (consumer code breaks) — immediate fix
- P1: Stale docs (consumer confused) — high priority
- P2: Incomplete docs (friction, eventual success) — medium
- P3: Terminology drift (confusion but survivable) — low
Parallel to diagnostic-strictness scale (cycles #57–#69). Both are
'truth-over-convenience' constraints.
Evidence: cycles #78–#79 found 2 P0 instances in USAGE.md and ERROR_HANDLING.md,
both related to JSON envelope shape. Root cause: SCHEMAS.md is aspirational (v2.0),
binary still emits v1.0, docs needed to be empirical not aspirational.
Going forward: doc audits compare against actual binary, flag P0 violations
immediately, link forward to migration plans (FIX_LOCUS_164.md).
The Python code examples were accessing nested error.kind like envelope['error']['kind'],
but v1.0 emits flat envelopes with error as a STRING and kind at top-level.
Updated:
- Table header: now shows actual v1.0 shape {error: "...", kind: "...", type: "error"}
- match statement: switched from envelope.get('error',{}).get('kind') to envelope.get('kind')
- All ClawError raises: changed from envelope['error']['message'] to envelope.get('error','')
because error field is a STRING in v1.0, not a nested object
- Added inline comments on every error case noting v1.0 vs v2.0 difference
- Appendix: split into v1.0 (actual/current) and v2.0 (target after FIX_LOCUS_164)
The code examples now work correctly against the actual binary.
This was active misdocumentation (P0 severity) — the Python examples would crash
if a consumer tried to use them.
The JSON output section was misleading — it claimed the binary emits
exit_code, command, timestamp, output_format, schema_version, and nested
error objects. The binary actually emits v1.0 flat shape (kind at top-level,
error as string, no common metadata fields).
Updated section:
- Documents actual v1.0 success and error envelope shapes
- Lists known issues (missing fields, overloaded kind, flat error)
- Shows how to dispatch on v1.0 (check type=='error' before reading kind)
- Warns users NOT to rely on kind alone
- Links to FIX_LOCUS_164.md for migration plan
- Explains Phase 1/2/3 timeline for v2.0 adoption
This is a doc-only fix that makes USAGE.md truthful about the current behavior
while preparing users for the coming schema migration.
Binary emits different envelope shape than SCHEMAS.md documents:
- Missing: timestamp, command, exit_code, output_format, schema_version
- Wrong placement: kind is top-level, not nested under error
- Extra: type:error field not in schema
- Wrong type: error is string, not object with operation/target/retryable
Additional issue: 'kind' field is semantically overloaded (verb-id in
success envelopes, error-kind in error envelopes) — violates typed contract.
Filed as 7th member of typed-error family (joins #102, #121, #127, #129, #130, #245).
Recommended fix: Option A — update binary to match schema (principled design).
Attempted cherry-pick of #248 (1 commit) onto main. Encountered 2 conflict zones
in main.rs (test definitions + error classification). Manual regex cleanup left
orphaned diff markers that Rust compiler rejected.
Decision: Rebase-bridge works for 1-conflict branches, but 2+ conflicts in 12K+-line
files require author context. Revised strategy: push main to origin, request branch
authors rebase locally with IDE support, then merge from updated origin branches.
Estimated timeline: 30 min for branch authors to rebase 8 branches in parallel.
Fresh dogfood found no new pinpoints. All core verbs working correctly.
Blocker: 8 remaining review-ready branches on origin have conflicts with
cycle #72's 4 merges. Root cause: remote branches predated the merge chain.
Example: feat/jobdori-127-verb-suffix-flags rebase fails on commit 3/3
because cycle #72 added 15+ new LocalHelpTopic variants.
Recommend: coordinate with branch authors to rebase against new main.
Cycle #74 will post integration checkpoint + queue status.
Backlog-truthfulness (cycle #60) validated: fresh dogfood on current main confirmed
#163 was closed by cycle #72's help-parity chain merge. Zero duplicate work.
Cleanup: removed /tmp/jobdori-163 worktree and fix/jobdori-163-help-help-selfref branch.
Fix: resolve actual HEAD path in git worktrees for correct Git SHA in build metadata.
In worktrees, .git is a pointer file not a directory, so cargo's rerun-if-changed=.git/HEAD never triggers.
Per MERGE_CHECKLIST.md Cluster 2 (P1 Diagnostic-strictness, isolated):
- 25 lines in build.rs only (no crate-level conflicts)
- Verified: build → commit → rebuild → SHA updates correctly
Diagnostic-strictness family member (joins #122/#122b).
Applied: execution artifact runbook. Cycle #72 integration.
Provides:
- Recommended merge order (P0 → P1 → P2 → P3 by cluster)
- Per-cluster merge prerequisites and validation steps
- Conflict risk assessment (Cluster 2 #122/#122b have same edit locus)
- Post-merge validation checklist (build + test + dogfood)
- Timeline estimate (~60 min for full 17-branch queue)
Addresses the final integration step: once branches are reviewed, knowing
the safe merge order matters. This artifact pre-answers that question.
Applied doctrine: integration-support artifacts (cycle #64) reduce reviewer
friction. At 17-branch saturation, a merge-safe checklist is first-class work.
Relates to cycle #70 integration throughput initiative.
Problem: In git worktrees, .git is a pointer file (not a directory), so cargo's
rerun-if-changed=.git/HEAD never triggers when commits are made. This causes
claw version to report a stale SHA after new commits.
Solution: Add resolve_git_head_path() helper that detects worktree mode:
- If .git is a file: parse gitdir pointer, watch <gitdir>/HEAD
- If .git is a directory: watch .git/HEAD (regular repo)
This ensures build.rs invalidates on each commit, making version output truthful.
Verification: Binary built in worktree now reports correct SHA after commits
(before: stale, after: current HEAD).
Relates to ROADMAP #161 (filed cycle #65, implemented cycle #69).
Diagnostic-strictness family member.
Diff: 21 lines added (resolve_git_head_path + conditional rerun-if-changed).
Verbs with CLI-reserved positional-arg meanings (resume, compact, memory,
commit, pr, issue, bughunter) were falling through to Prompt dispatch
when invoked with args, causing users to see 'missing_credentials' errors
instead of guidance that the verb is a slash command.
#160 investigation revealed the underlying design question: which verbs
are 'promptable' (can start a prompt like 'explain this pattern') vs.
'reserved' (have specific CLI meaning like 'resume SESSION_ID')?
This fix implements the reserved-verb classification: at parse time,
intercept reserved verbs with trailing args and emit slash-command guidance
before falling through to Prompt. Promptable verbs (explain, bughunter, clear)
continue to route to Prompt as before.
Helper: is_reserved_semantic_verb() lists the reserved set.
All 181 tests pass (no regressions).
## What Was Broken
`claw doctor` reported "Status: ok" when run from ~/ or /, but `claw
prompt` in the same directory would error out with:
error: claw is running from a very broad directory (/Users/yeongyu).
The agent can read and search everything under this path.
Diagnostic deception: doctor said green, prompt said red. User runs
doctor to check their setup, sees all green, runs prompt, gets blocked.
Trust in doctor erodes.
This is the exact pattern captured in the 'Diagnostic Commands Must Be
At Least As Strict As Runtime Commands' principle recorded in ROADMAP.md
at cycle #57.
## Root Cause
Two code paths perform the broad-cwd check:
- CliAction::Prompt handler → `enforce_broad_cwd_policy()` (errors out)
- CliAction::Repl handler → same function
But render_doctor_report() never called detect_broad_cwd(). The workspace
health check only looked at whether cwd was inside a git project, not
whether cwd was a dangerously broad path.
## What This Fix Does
Extend `check_workspace_health()` to also probe `detect_broad_cwd()`:
let broad_cwd = detect_broad_cwd();
let (level, summary) = match (in_repo, &broad_cwd) {
(_, Some(path)) => (
DiagnosticLevel::Warn,
format!(
"current directory is a broad path ({}); Prompt/REPL will \
refuse to run here without --allow-broad-cwd",
path.display()
),
),
(true, None) => (DiagnosticLevel::Ok, "project root detected"),
(false, None) => (DiagnosticLevel::Warn, "not inside a git project"),
};
The check now warns about BOTH failure modes with clear messaging about
what Prompt/REPL will do.
## Dogfood Verification
Before fix:
$ cd ~ && claw doctor
Workspace
Status warn
Summary current directory is not inside a git project
[all green otherwise]
$ echo | claw prompt "test"
error: claw is running from a very broad directory (/Users/yeongyu)...
After fix:
$ cd ~ && claw doctor
Workspace
Status warn
Summary current directory is a broad path (/Users/yeongyu);
Prompt/REPL will refuse to run here without
--allow-broad-cwd
$ cd / && claw doctor
Workspace
Status warn
Summary current directory is a broad path (/); ...
Non-regression:
$ cd /tmp/my-project && claw doctor
Workspace
Status warn
Summary current directory is not inside a git project
(unchanged)
$ cd /path/to/real/git/project && claw doctor
Workspace
Status ok
Summary project root detected on branch main
(unchanged)
## Regression Tests Added
- `workspace_check_in_project_dir_reports_ok` — non-broad + in-project = OK
- `workspace_check_outside_project_reports_warn` — non-broad + not-in-project = Warn with 'not inside git project' summary
- 181 binary tests pass (was 179, added 2)
## Related
- Principle: 'Diagnostic Commands Must Be At Least As Strict As Runtime
Commands' (ROADMAP.md cycle #57)
- Companion to #122 (stale-base preflight in doctor)
- Sibling: next step is probably a full runtime-vs-doctor audit for
other asymmetries (auth, sandbox, plugins, hooks)
